Casting is of vital importance to a film. Without matching the right actor to the right character, even masters of the craft can give poor performances that bring down the movie as a whole. Superhero movies, centered around their larger-than-life characters, especially need to nail this aspect of filmmaking.
One of the most acclaimed superhero castings ever is that of Tobey Maguire as Peter Parker in Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man trilogy, with many viewing Maguire as perfectly encapsulating Parker’s earnest likability. There are other castings as acclaimed, or even moreso, across a range of superhero franchises.
10 Margot Robbie Makes Harley Quinn In Front Of & Behind The Camera
2016’s Suicide Squad is a movie panned for nearly everything, but widely agreed to have good casting. By far the standout of the film is Margot Robbie as Harley Quinn, in the first live-action movie outing for the character. Putting a unique and modern spin on the character that nonetheless is recognizable from the comic books, Robbie’s performance is beloved.
Since then, Robbie has played the character twice more in Birds of Prey, and The Suicide Squad. In addition to bringing life to the character and having the physicality to do many of her stunts as well, Robbie has also served as a producer for Birds of Prey, helping to perfect the movie’s portrayal of the character even further.
9 Patrick Stewart Brings Hope To Life As Charles Xavier
The casting of the X-Men films is often applauded, particularly as the dual timelines of the films mean that certain key roles need to be cast twice. Nonetheless, few of its casting choices have been more beloved than that of veteran actor Patrick Stewart as the central Charles Xavier, all the way from 2000’s X-Men through to 2017’s Logan.
Stewart brings to the role the perfect sort of gravitas that Professor X needs, making it perfectly clear how and why the other members of the team—and mutants as a whole—look to him as a father figure. Through Stewart’s performance, Xavier’s passion and hope shine through, but also his gentleness.
8 Florence Pugh Charms As Yelena Belova
Of the Marvel Cinematic Universe‘s Phase 4, Yelena Belova stands out as one of its most widely-liked characters. Appearing in both Black Widow and Hawkeye, the character is often considered to have stolen the show, and fans of the franchise are anxious to see more of her.
A large part of that is due to Florence Pugh’s performance. Although the character has marked differences from her comic book counterpart, the version of Yelena that graces the MCU has become a force in her own right. Through Pugh’s performance, the character can switch between charming to hilarious, relatable, and lethal all within the space of a scene.
7 Jason Momoa Helps To Bolster Arthur Curry In The Eyes Of Many
For a long while, Aquaman was something of a punchline to jokes about superheroes in general. Not helped by several poor depictions, he was viewed as weak and unnecessary, with incredibly circumstantial powers that made it difficult to take him seriously.
In recent years, his reputation has been rehabilitated significantly. Although this is in part due to better depictions in the comics, it has been greatly helped by Jason Momoa’s performance in the character in the DCEU. In both Justice League and Aquaman, Momoa makes the character impressive, attractive, and undeniably engaging—all without losing a sense of comedy.
6 Robert Downey Jr. Nails Iron Man’s Mannerisms
As the founding and central character of the MCU, the casting of Tony Stark for 2008’s Iron Man was a big question. At the time, many questioned casting Robert Downey Jr., whose reputation was still struggling to recover after a series of notorious legal difficulties.
After that first movie, however, few were questioning it. Downey, in the many, many films in which he plays the role of Stark, embodies the character perfectly. Even aside from his wit and hedonism, he also makes clear the character’s hidden good side, his genuine fears, and his struggles with others. Throughout the Infinity Saga, few can question that Downey underpins the entire franchise.
5 Samuel L. Jackson Shines With Less Material As Frozone
Samuel L. Jackson has appeared in a number of superhero projects, from Mr. Glass in M. Night Shyamalan’s Unbreakable and Glass, and Nick Fury in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, to Frozone in The Incredibles and its sequel. Despite the comparatively smaller role of Frozone in the films, he quickly became one of the most widely-liked characters in The Incredibles.
The character’s genuinely compassionate nature, mixed with his frequent exasperation all serve to mold Jackson well to the character. With his voice alone, he is able to create a hugely enjoyable and thoroughly believable member of the superhero world, and one who is at the center of some of the best scenes in the movies.
4 Hugh Jackman Is Logan In Spirit, If Not In Body
Although he shares the limelight with many others, Logan is the central character for much of the X-Men film franchise, played by Hugh Jackman. In an interesting case, Jackman is physically almost nothing like the character in the comic books—who is short and unattractive—and no efforts are made to reconcile the two.
Instead, Jackman pours his effort into the character’s mindset and personality. From his brusque personality to his hidden heart of gold, his reluctant heroism, and his deep emotional pain, Jackman perfectly conveys the sort of person Logan is. The performance is considered one of the best in any superhero franchise, perfectly demonstrated in Logan.
3 Chadwick Boseman Made T’Challa A True King
In every film in which he appeared, T’Challa stood out as one of the most interesting and likable characters in the MCU. From his central roles in Black Panther and Captain America: Civil War, to his more minor but impactful parts in Infinity War and Endgame, T’Challa managed to establish himself alongside the other giants of the franchise like Iron Man and Captain America.
A huge part of that was due to Chadwick Boseman’s portrayal. Boseman gave T’Challa every bit of the genuine regal dignity he deserved, while still showing him as a fallible human who could let his guard down around his loved ones and succeeded in doing the right thing when every option seemed wrong. So beloved was Boseman’s performance that, after his tragic death, many fans expressed a wish to not see the character recast—which Marvel respected.
2 Gal Gadot Stands Out As Diana Prince
Despite the largely-negative reception to Batman v. Superman, one of the things the film receives credit for is the inclusion of Gal Gadot as Diana Prince, serving to introduce her before she becomes a greater figure in the wider DCEU. Every part of the character is popular, but a widely-celebrated part is Gal Gadot’s acting, whether in ensemble movies or solo outings.
The character—being the only child on a secluded island of Amazon women, who is introduced to the crueler wide world—is a hard one to bring across, but Gadot manages perfectly. With films shifting back and forth along the timeline, she is able to display both Diana’s wide-eyed naïveté, and her later cynical optimism following the events of her solo films.
1 Michael Fassbender Makes Erik Lehnsherr Undeniably Human
The character of Erik Lehnsherr is one of the most integral to the entire X-Men film franchise, being the iconic antagonist who, ultimately, has sympathetic motivations and origins, but does terrible things in pursuit of those. Both actors cast in the role, Ian McKellen and Michael Fassbender, have received acclaim for their portrayals, and both are widely beloved.
Neither is better than the other, but Fassbender shines as a perfect casting because of how rawly human he makes his version of Magneto. Under his portrayal, the already-sympathetic figure becomes almost mythic in his struggle with oppression and his own mortality, and the viewer can’t help but be drawn in. Even in panned movies, Fassbender’s acting is considered perfect.
About The Author
