Across his various iterations, Batman typically has a standard set of rules and aspects that can’t be challenged. One of the most consistent, especially in the modern era, is his rule against killing. Although some versions of the character — such as his earliest Golden Age comics appearances and the versions that appeared in Tim Burton and Zack Snyder’s films — didn’t adhere to this, it is usually a fundamental element of the superhero.
That’s what makes the accidental betrayal of it in one film so surprising. One of the definitive moments of the Dark Knight Trilogy was Bruce Wayne’s refusal to become a member of the League of Shadows if it meant committing a murder. But in the process, he also quietly betrayed his morals by seemingly murdering the man he tried to spare.
The Nolan version of Bruce Wayne was largely defined throughout Batman Begins, with a lengthy portion of the film dedicated to his origins, his eventual departure from Gotham and how he became a student of Ra’s Al Ghul. While training with the League of Shadows, however, Bruce was introduced to their ideal of justice — having captured a farmer-turned murderer, the League fully intended to eventually execute him for the crime. After passing his various physical, mental and psychological tests, Bruce was set to be inducted into the League. He was even secretly set up to become an advance agent for the fall of Gotham, meant as a blow to the corrupt city it had become in the absence of his parents. And his final step was to prove his resolve and execute the farmer himself.
However, in a moment of characteristic restraint, Wayne refused. Arguing it wasn’t his place to carry out such a sentence and that they needed to be better men than the criminals they fought, Wayne refused to become an executioner. A fight quickly broke out, with Wayne’s refusal leading to a chain of events that largely wiped out the League of Shadows, destroyed their mountain-top fortress and nearly killed Ra’s himself. Wayne then escaped and returned to Gotham to use the lessons he’d learned to become Batman. It was an act of mercy that set Wayne on the path to becoming more than the League of Shadows could ever imagine, turning him into a hero. But it was also likely for nothing, considering the fact that Wayne likely sort of killed the man he spared.
RELATED: Batman’s Michael Keaton On Clashing With Schumacher Over ‘Dark’ Bruce Wayne
Since the criminal Wayne spared was tied up and likely starved from his time in a small wooden cage, it’s unlikely he was in the best condition to escape the chaos of the exploding League of Shadows fortress. While Wayne didn’t intend to kill anyone in his attempt to escape, it’s clear in the ensuing carnage that multiple members of the League died. If the highly trained agents of the night weren’t able to escape the firey chaos, then it’s less likely that a weakened former farmer had much of a chance to escape either. Although Wayne’s technical slaughter of the League of Shadows wasn’t his intent, it still happened — prompting Ra’s himself to later confront Wayne in Gotham City. In fact, it’s even probable that the criminal Wayne tried to spare was killed in the explosion — a potentially far worse demise than a beheading.
Nolan’s Batman had a far looser interpretation of murder than other incarnations of the character. He would later refuse to save Ra’s at the conclusion of Batman Begins, leaving him to die aboard an out-of-control train. He would later be personally responsible for the death of Harvey Dent in The Dark Knight (by tackling him off a building to save Gordon’s son) and Talia al Ghul in The Dark Knight Rises (by firing upon her in his Bat-Wing). But going all the way back to one of his first acts in the trilogy, even before he would don cowl and cape of Batman, Wayne had accidentally racked up a body count — even someone he tried to show mercy to. In essence, a moment that defined Bruce Wayne’s morality in this universe was predicated on mercy, which was then immediately rendered moot by his actions.
KEEP READING: The Bat And The Cat Make A Helluva Duet In The Batman Promo
About The Author
