Dungeons & Dragons is a tabletop-RPG filled with rich lore, immersive realms and centuries of in-world history. Fifth Edition‘s universe has expanded from multiple planes in the same universe to a full multiverse, making it a very story-forward system. The game, of course, includes combat, but problems can arises when trying to balance storytelling and role-playing with battles.
Many Dungeons Masters struggle to merge the combat and storytelling aspects of D&D. 5e‘s combat system is great, but single fights can take a while to get through, and battles tend to focus on rules, mechanics and dice rolls with little to no role-playing or storytelling. This can make combat feel like an entirely separate game. However, there are things that DMs can do to make combat feel more plot-relevant and give players chances to role-play during fights.
Adding NPCs to D&D Combat
One of the easiest things a DM can do to change up combat and make it feel more interesting and dynamic is to add an NPC to the fight. This could be a character the players have encountered before or a new character the DM wishes to introduce. Players can even be set up to contend with an NPC’s betrayal. Perhaps an enemy encounter is threatening a beloved tavern keeper, or a member of the city guard the party has worked with before is being overwhelmed by a raid. Situations like this are great for motivating players to take part in the fight, adding some flavor and opening up role-playing opportunities during the encounter.
Introducing a D&D Villain
A great way to introduce a major campaign villain is to have the players face them in a fight. This is even more effective if the villain shows up in the middle of an encounter that’s already in progress. Introducing the main villain ahead of the final boss fight against them will add weight to that villain both as a character and a threat, showing the players what the villain might be capable of. A villain showing up to turn the tide of a fight well before the players intend to meet them can make them really ponder what it is they are dealing with, especially if said villain is significantly more powerful than the rest of the encounter.
Tailor the Random D&D Encounter Tables
Any game that focuses on exploration or takes place in the wilderness will likely make use of random encounter tables. In more recent published campaigns, random encounter tables have been made much more interesting, but older pre-made adventures will essentially throw monsters at the party without much context.
The best way to avoid this is for the DM to tailor their encounter table (whether it comes from an official book or another source) to their specific game. This can mean focusing on certain types of monsters or certain factions, or it can mean creating a random encounter that links directly to the main plot of the campaign. Things such as “1d12 goblins show up to attack the party” can be changed to “1d12 goblins have been tracking the party to steal an artifact they are protecting and take this moment to attack.” Small changes like this provide more context and flavor to the fight, keeping players invested in the storyline that is being told.
D&D Stories Within Combat
Combat encounters are also a great place for small-scale role-playing moments to occur. The biggest aid to this is in how the DM narrates the action. Not every sword stroke or spell has to be a larger-than-life moment, but adding a little flair to an attack can help sell the encounter and make it feel more engaging. Instead saying, “A 16 hits, roll the damage,” it’s much more interesting if the DM says something along the lines of, “You are able to knock his shield out of the way and land a clean blow — now roll damage for that.” Another great way to keep combat flowing narratively is to have players narrate what their own attacks look like. This can also give each character a unique flair to how they fight, making them more personal to the player controlling them.
Changing The Stakes In A D&D Fight
The best way to tie combat to the story of a campaign is with additional stakes and consequences. Often, the stakes of an encounter are simply “kill the enemy before they kill you.” The addition of NPCs or more immediate stakes can improve the feel of a fight a great degree. The DM should always consider what the immediate goal of an encounter is. If the goal is only killing all the enemies, it can be helpful to consider alternative objectives instead. Things as simple as reaching the other side of a room or capturing the enemy leader alive can add more interest to an encounter and allow for more role-playing potential.
While combat is one of the core mechanics of D&D, the focus of combat doesn’t need to be on mechanics and dice alone. Adding any of these elements to an encounter will liven up the party’s fights and make for much more memorable and enjoyable sessions.
About The Author